CAN WE PULL UP THE WEEDS

CroJack

Key Player
I watched the game from the 18th minute, and we were actually playing well considering how good Leeds are. It's obvious that:

- we desperately lack pace in all positions,
- we desperately lack quality in some positions,
- our centre-backs are error-prone,
- we don't have clinical goal-scorers up front,
- we are too slow in transitions,
- we don't commit enough bodies up front when we attack.
 

Yankee_Jack

Key Player
Yates is not the #9 solution. He doesn't challenge nor win anything in the air, and since neither does Cullen (much), would prefer to see him lead the line and make his runs with his finishing ability than stuck right midfield. Since the headline on Yates is that he "works" hard, then if he's not totally knackered by minute 60, he's not successful and not getting it done.

We had the absurd situation against Leeds, where Cullen was sub'd on for Cooper and played in that right midfield slot with Pato and Yates further forward. Then, a few minutes later Walsh was sub'd on for Pato ... and assumed Pato's position and role. Instead, Cullen and Walsh should have swapped at that point. Common sense, No? Not for Duffer. Two square pegs in two round holes.

And then there was Darling trying to play right back against Leeds' most potent players ... laughable.
 

ivoralljack

Grizzled Veteran
Staff member
I've given up on Duff: some time ago in fact. Cullen needs an EXTENDED run up front in the middle. Who the hell told him that it would be a good idea to play him wide or in midfield? Duff just can't see it. But if Bolasie gets himself games on the wing, he has the ability to service the penalty area from there. Should that happen, and Bolasie's cameo was promising enough to make it realistic, we need our best finisher in the box and that's Cullen. Not just my opinion but also the opinions of Trunds, Curt, Leon, KOL and Tosh junior. But Liam needs time to become attuned again to that position - hence why I said he needs an extended run there to find his rhythm and revive the predatory instincts that Duff has done his level best to kill.
 

jackodiamonds

Set-Piece Specialist
Staff member
Yates scored 15 for Blackpool. He's a capable goalscorer but he's being misused by Duff (not the only one). About the only thing he does now is press the goalkeeper and central defenders when they have possession, and even then it's not balls-to-the-wall gegenpressing, just normal pressure. I have to believe he is being instructed to play the way he is playing by Duff, because there's no way he scores 15 goals if he played the same for Blackpool.

Looking at some of his goals for Blackpool there's an even mix of set-piece target-man goals and open-play strikes, but there's one or two showing he's got more skill than we've seen and can actually find space. I hope that if Bolasie can serve up more of those crosses we saw vs Leeds then Yates might come good, but it's still insane that Cullen is being kept out of the #9 role. I swear if every other striker was injured Duff would play Darling at 9 before Cullen.
 

ivoralljack

Grizzled Veteran
Staff member
Whilst we played okay for short spells, over the whole game Leeds showed the greater quality and Duff had no idea how to counter it. A master tactician he's not and he shows this every week. Some stats:

POSSESSION: 50-50 SHOTS: 18-10 OT: 8-2 PASSES: 455-450 TOUCHES IN OPPO BOX: 34-12 CORNERS: 6-5 FOULS: 12-11 GOALS: 3-1

Interesting to note that the stats for possession, passes, corners and fouls were pretty even but the rest stood out in sharp contrast. What is glaringly evident is that Leeds made far better use of the ball than we did - they had almost THREE TIMES the touches in our box than we did in theirs and were by far the more effective team.

Okay, I accept that the overall quality of their players is better than ours but Duff had no idea how to negate that either by his tactics, his substitutions and the unfamiliar roles he asked some of his players to adopt. I think Duff must have invented the concept of square pegs in round holes so lacking is he in the ability to make the best use of his playing assets.

Leeds attacked in numbers, defended in numbers and were competitive all over the park. For a team to do this requires each player to be at peak fitness and I have long doubted the fitness levels of our squad. Pace is God given - you either have it or you don't - but stamina, strength and the ability to run for 90 minutes can be acquired with the proper training. Somehow, when I look at our team, I don't see acceptable levels of training and I definitely don't see evidence of any coaching which is improving our players.

Unfortunately we have a manager from the lower leagues and we are now playing like a lower league team.
 

jackodiamonds

Set-Piece Specialist
Staff member
Leeds are playing with a lot of confidence, and Swansea really aren't. How many passes went awry on Wednesday night? And I'm not talking about general sloppy passing, I'm talking about those absolute misses, where it's clear the players aren't on the same page and the ball ends up 15 yards from anyone.

e.g. Cullen switched the ball to nobody late on, with both Bolasie and Lowe looking at each other and then at Cullen, who had clearly expected one of them to read his intention, while Leeds get a throw-in. Fair enough on Bolasie, he's new, but I counted perhaps 3 total misses like that.

Might not sound like much, but there was once a time when Renato Sanches was the butt of the entire Premier League for passing to an advertising hoarding, and that happened once in the seven years Swansea were in the big league. That kind of thing is happening multiple times per game atm. Perhaps not to that extent, but near enough. The players are not on the same page, and it looks like half the team clearly has a different idea of the expected tactical set-up to the other half.

No wonder these players lack confidence. A manager's first and singularly most important job is to unite the dressing room and make the players believe they are world-beaters. A confident team plays with freedom and its players read the game situation and each other well enough to make the right decisions more often than not, so the tactics don't need to be complicated. Just a few core principles and a basic shape. That's what Leeds have going on.

It's really hard to back Duff when the players are making those kind of mistakes this far into a season. Also, Leeds scored their 3rd goal in the 61st minute, yet Duff didn't make any changes until the 70th. What did he think was going to happen in those 9 minutes to justify holding off on the subs? The game was done. Swansea hadn't had one meaningful attack in the second half. Did he really think that third goal was going to inspire them to a comeback in a way he obviously can't?

The moment that third Leeds goal goes in, he should have pulled Pato, Fulton and Yates (the first two - who played well - to keep them fresh for the next game, and Yates because he'd done nothing). He could have learned so much over the last half hour by making some significant changes and seeing what could happen (Cullen at 9 would be a start). At least he'd have made use of the defeat. Instead, he sat on his hands and wasted 9 minutes for absolutely no reason I can fathom.

Duff's team are following his example - standing around looking bemused for most of the match and then doing too little, too late. I don't understand how a manager who preaches high-intensity can be so passive.
 

CroJack

Key Player
If I was (a clueless) Swansea manager, like Duff, and if my system wasn't effective, then I would have a look at Ipswich stats, analyse them, and try to do what they do.

Ipswich:

Shooting

1st for number of shots
1st for number of shots on target
1st for number of goals scored
1st for expected goals (chances created)

Pressing

5th for build up disruption
5th for gegenpressing
6th for number of allowed passes per defensive action (PPDA)

Crossing

4th for successful crosses

Tackling

1st for tackles won


Swansea

Shooting

20th for number of shots
15th for number of shots on target
14th for goals scored
13 for expected goals

Pressing ("we'll get into their faces" is what Duff promised in the begining of this season)

18th for build up disruption
15th for gegenpressing
14th for number of allowed passes per defensive action

Crossing

17th for successful crosses

Tackling

15th for tackles won
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom